The short answer
A good fake IW328070 gets you most of the look for a fraction of the money, and the gap that is left is where all the arguing happens. On the wrist, in normal light, almost nobody will call it. In your hand, under a lamp, with the caseback off, the differences are plain: dial printing sharpness, crown feel, caseback engraving depth, and the movement itself. If the watch has a display back, the movement is the whole conversation.
What this reference is, and why it is easy to copy
IW328070 sits in IWC's Portofino family: a small dress automatic with a clean three-hand dial, slim bezel, and a case built from mostly flat surfaces. That matters for replicas. A watch like this has very little to hide behind. There is no chronograph pusher stack, no dive bezel with 120 clicks, no complicated bracelet. It is a round case, a dial, hands, and a strap. The simpler the object, the easier it is to machine close to the original.
It also means the flaws are easier to spot. There is nowhere to look except the details.
Where the replica gets it right
- Case proportions. Most decent reps of this reference nail the diameter and the thin profile. A dress watch that sits too tall is an instant tell, and the better factories know it.
- The dial layout. No date window alignment problems, no subdial spacing issues. Plain and clean is forgiving.
- The strap. Leather is cheap to source and easy to match.
- Weight in the hand. With a similar case size and a metal movement, the heft lands close enough that you will not notice without a scale.
Where it slips
Dial printing and indices
I look at the logo first, then the minute track, then the applied markers. Genuine IWC printing is crisp under 10x, with clean edges on every letter and consistent spacing. Reps tend to look heavy, like the ink spread. Applied indices on fakes often sit a hair proud of the dial or catch light at a different angle than the hands.
Crown and tube
This is the cheapest tell and the one most people miss. Screw the crown down. Genuine should feel like a well-machined bolt: smooth, no grit, a definite stop. Fakes often feel loose at the last half turn or grind a little. Pull it to the setting position and check for wobble.
Crystal and AR coating
A genuine dress IWC has a crystal that nearly disappears at an angle, with a faint blue or purple tint depending on the coating batch. Reps either skip the coating or lay it on too thick, and you get a mirror effect under office lighting. Tilt the watch toward a window and watch for a milky reflection.
Caseback engraving and finish
Engraving on the genuine is cut deep and consistent. On fakes it is often laser-etched shallow, and the reference numbers look soft at the edges. Run a fingernail across it. You should feel a wall, not a scratch.
The movement is the real split
If the reference has a display back, the comparison ends there. Genuine IWC automatics use a calibre built on a Sellita base, regulated and finished in Schaffhausen, with a decorated rotor and a set beat rate. Replicas usually run a Miyota 9015 or a clone of a Swiss automatic. Both keep time fine. Neither looks like the real thing through glass.
Listen, too. A Miyota rotor spins freely and rattles when you flick your wrist. The genuine rotor is heavier and quieter. That sound is the fastest check I know, and it needs no tools.
The money math
Here is the part people skip. The genuine is an entry-level luxury watch, not a six-figure grail. That changes the calculation. A replica saves you real money up front, but a genuine holds value, comes with service history, and can be sold. A fake is worth what someone will pay you on a forum, which is close to nothing once the next batch ships.
Add a service on a rep movement every few years and the gap narrows more than the sticker price suggests. If you want the look for occasional wear, the math works. If you want one watch to keep for a decade, it does not.
My five-minute check
- Print quality on the dial under 10x, especially the logo and the minute track.
- Crown threading: smooth down, no grit, firm stop.
- Engraving depth on the caseback, felt with a fingernail.
- Crystal reflection at an angle, looking for milkiness.
- Rotor sound and feel, wrist flick, ear close.
Who should skip it
If you plan to sell later, if you care about service history, or if the watch will sit next to a genuine one on a tray, skip the fake. If you want a clean dress watch for a wedding or an interview and you are honest with yourself that it is a costume piece, the rep does the job and nobody at the table will know.
Bottom line
Fake IW328070 vs genuine is not a close fight under magnification, and it is nearly a tie at arm's length. Buy the rep for the look, buy the real one for the ownership. Do not buy the rep expecting it to be the real one, and you will be fine.